Study vocabulary from this article
Use flashcards with SRS system for long-term retention
In every essay I grade, vague pronouns appear like clockwork. A student writes “She told her friend that she needed to bring her homework,” and I stop and ask: which she? Which her? The reader gets confused, and so does the writer. Vague pronouns are one of the most common clarity problems in English writing — and they’re also one of the easiest to fix once you know what to look for.
You’ll teaches you to spot vague pronouns before they derail your reader, understand why they’re a problem, and use three simple strategies to eliminate them from your writing. Your sentences will be clearer, more professional, and easier for readers to follow.
Key Takeaways
- A vague pronoun lacks a clear antecedent — the reader can’t tell who or what the pronoun refers to.
- The most common culprits — it, this, that, they, and they when the subject is ambiguous.
- Reader confusion is a real problem — forcing readers to reread sentences damages clarity and professionalism.
- Three fixes that work — use a specific noun, repeat the antecedent, or rephrase the sentence.
- Prevention is easier than fixing — slow down while writing and ask “who or what does this pronoun refer to?”
What Is a Vague Pronoun?
A vague pronoun is any pronoun whose antecedent (the noun it replaces) is unclear, missing, or too distant from the pronoun itself. The reader encounters the pronoun and feels confused about what it refers to.
Example (vague): “Sarah told Michelle that she was promoted.”
Who was promoted — Sarah or Michelle? The pronoun “she” could refer to either person, so it’s vague.
Example (clear): “Sarah told Michelle that Sarah had been promoted.”
Now it’s clear: Sarah was promoted. By repeating the noun instead of using a pronoun, we eliminate the ambiguity.
The key rule: a pronoun is only clear if the reader can immediately and confidently identify what it refers to.
Common Types of Vague Pronouns
| Vague Pronoun | Problem | Example | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| It | No clear singular noun | I went to the store, and it was busy. | …and the store was busy. |
| They | Unclear plural referent | They said the project was late. | The team said the project was late. |
| This / That | Refers to general idea, not noun | He forgot his keys. This was a problem. | …This forgetfulness was a problem. |
| That | Too far from antecedent | I read three books and a magazine. That was great. | The magazine was great. |
| She / He | Multiple female/male nouns in sentence | Emma told Lily she should apply. | Emma told Lily to apply. |
Why Vague Pronouns Are a Problem
Reader Confusion and Frustration
When a pronoun is vague, readers must pause, reread the sentence, and try to figure out what the pronoun means. This breaks their concentration and slows down comprehension. In academic, professional, or journalistic writing, this confusion damages your credibility.
Example: “The teacher handed the report to the student and told him it was excellent.”
Wait — did the teacher praise the report or the student? The pronoun “it” is unclear. Is “it” the report or something else? A careful reader has to backtrack.
Misinterpretation of Meaning
Sometimes readers make a guess about what the pronoun refers to — and they guess wrong. This leads to misunderstanding, especially dangerous in professional or technical writing.
Example: “John bought the computer for his son, but he didn’t like it.”
Does the son dislike the computer? Or does John dislike the idea of giving it? Both interpretations are possible, and the reader will make a choice based on limited information.
Unprofessional Tone
Vague pronouns make writing sound careless and imprecise. Readers may conclude that if you’re unclear with pronouns, you’re unclear with your ideas too. In professional emails, reports, and resumes, clarity is essential.
Common Mistakes with Vague Pronouns
✗ Incorrect: “When the committee met with the board, they agreed on a timeline.”
✓ Correct: “When the committee met with the board, the committee agreed on a timeline.” (Or: “…the board agreed…”)
Why: “They” could refer to the committee OR the board. Repeating the noun removes ambiguity.
✗ Incorrect: “I uploaded the files to the server, but it crashed before I could save them.”
✓ Correct: “I uploaded the files to the server, but the server crashed before I could save them.”
Why: “It” is vague — what crashed? The server, the computer, or the application? Name the noun directly.
✗ Incorrect: “The report was late, which was frustrating.”
✓ Correct: “The report’s lateness was frustrating.” (Or: “The late report frustrated everyone.”)
Why: “Which” refers to an entire idea, not a specific noun. Restructure to make the problem clear.
✗ Incorrect: “Maria told Elena that she had won the scholarship.”
✓ Correct: “Maria told Elena that Maria had won the scholarship.” (Or restructure: “Maria won the scholarship and told Elena about it.”)
Why: “She” could mean either person. Use a name or restructure to clarify.
How to Identify Vague Pronouns in Your Writing
When editing your work, apply this simple test to every pronoun: Can I point to one and only one noun that the pronoun refers to?
If you hesitate, if you think “well, it could be this OR that,” you have a vague pronoun. Mark it and revise.
Pronouns to Watch
Certain pronouns are more prone to vagueness:
- It — often has no clear antecedent (“They’re reading it aloud” — what is “it”?)
- This / That — often refers to an entire clause rather than a specific noun (“We finished early, which surprised everyone.”)
- They / Them — easy to use when the subject is unclear (“They said to call back tomorrow.” Who?)
- He / She — problematic when multiple people of the same gender are mentioned
Three Strategies to Fix Vague Pronouns
Strategy 1: Use a Specific Noun Instead of a Pronoun
The simplest fix: replace the vague pronoun with the actual noun. This is almost always clearer.
Vague: “The manager told the team that they had completed their objectives.”
Clear: “The manager told the team that the team had completed their objectives.” (Or: “…that they [the team] had completed…”)
Vague: “I visited the museum yesterday. It was incredible.”
Clear: “I visited the museum yesterday. The museum was incredible.”
Strategy 2: Repeat the Antecedent When Necessary
If repeating a name or noun sounds awkward in Strategy 1, restructure the sentence to position the antecedent closer to the pronoun or use both.
Vague: “Sarah discussed the report with Emily. She said it was thorough.”
Clear: “Sarah discussed the report with Emily and said the report was thorough.” (Restructure to clarify who said what.)
Clear (alternative): “Sarah said the report was thorough when discussing it with Emily.”
Strategy 3: Rephrase the Sentence Completely
Sometimes the best solution is to restructure the entire sentence to make the reference crystal clear.
Vague: “When the students received their grades, it was disappointing.”
Clear (restructured): “The students were disappointed when they received their grades.”
Vague: “John gave the painting to his sister, and he kept one for himself. He valued it highly.”
Clear (restructured): “John gave a painting to his sister and kept one for himself. He valued his own painting highly.”
Sample Dialogue: Fixing Vague Pronouns
Editor: “I reviewed your draft. This is unclear.” (Points to sentence.)
Writer: “What’s the problem? It seems clear to me.”
Editor: “Your pronoun ‘it’ — what does it refer to? The policy or the deadline?”
Writer: “Oh! The deadline. I see it now. Let me rewrite: ‘The deadline was unclear.'”
Editor: “Perfect. That’s much clearer. Now readers don’t have to guess.”
Tip for writers: Read your work aloud. When you hear a vague pronoun, your ear often catches it before your eyes do. Pause and ask yourself: “What is ‘this’ or ‘it’ or ‘they’ referring to?” If you have to think about it, so will your reader.
Vague Pronouns in Different Types of Writing
Academic Writing
Vague: “The experiment showed that the chemical reaction was faster at higher temperatures. This was significant.”
Clear: “The experiment showed that the chemical reaction accelerated at higher temperatures. This acceleration was significant.”
In academic writing, precision matters. Journal editors and professors expect clarity.
Professional Email
Vague: “I sent the proposal to the client yesterday. They said it was good.”
Clear: “I sent the proposal to the client yesterday. The client approved it.”
Creative Writing
Even in fiction, vague pronouns confuse readers. However, creative writers sometimes use deliberate ambiguity for effect — but this should be intentional, not accidental.
Quick Quiz: Spotting and Fixing Vague Pronouns
Quick Quiz
Identify the vague pronoun and suggest a fix:
- Vague: “The CEO met with the vice president. She said the merger was approved.” — Who approved it? (Rewrite for clarity.)
- Vague: “I read three books last week. It was my favorite.” — What does “it” refer to? (Fix it.)
- Vague: “They announced the winner yesterday.” — Who is “they”? (Specify.)
- Vague: “The package arrived, but it was damaged.” — Clear or vague? (Explain.)
- Vague: “Sarah told Jessica that she needed a break.” — Who needs a break? (Clarify.)
Possible Answers: 1. Rewrite: “The CEO told the vice president that the merger was approved.” 2. “I read three books last week. The first one was my favorite.” 3. “The company announced the winner yesterday.” 4. Clear (it = package). 5. “Sarah told Jessica that Sarah needed a break.” (Or: “Sarah told Jessica, ‘I need a break.'”)
Related Articles
- ↑ Master Pillar: English Grammar
- They/Them Pronouns: Gender-Neutral Usage — careful use of they
- Mastering Male Pronouns: He, Him, His
- Fae Pronouns: A Neopronoun Guide
- ↑ Back to pillar: English Pronouns (Pillar)
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a vague pronoun?
A vague pronoun is one whose antecedent (the noun it refers to) is unclear, missing, or ambiguous. The reader cannot confidently identify what the pronoun refers to.
What are the most common vague pronouns?
The most common are “it,” “this,” “that,” “they,” and pronouns like “she/he” when multiple people of the same gender are mentioned in the sentence.
How can I identify a vague pronoun in my writing?
Ask yourself: “What noun does this pronoun refer to?” If you can’t point to a single, clear noun, the pronoun is vague. When in doubt, reread the sentence aloud — your ear often catches vagueness your eyes miss.
Is “it” always vague?
No. “It” is clear when the antecedent is obvious: “I found my keys. It was in the pocket.” (It = keys). But “it” becomes vague when multiple nouns precede it or when the antecedent is implied rather than stated.
Can I use “they” as a singular pronoun?
Yes, “they/them/theirs” is increasingly accepted as a singular, gender-neutral pronoun. However, make sure the antecedent is clear: “The customer called; they said they would arrive late” is clear because “they” = “the customer.”
What should I do if I find vague pronouns in my first draft?
Mark them and revise using one of three strategies: (1) replace the pronoun with a specific noun, (2) restructure the sentence to clarify the antecedent, or (3) rephrase entirely to avoid the ambiguity.
Quick Test: Check Your Understanding
5 questions to test what you've learned. No sign-up required.